Should the Atlanta Braves sign Trevor Bauer?
Owing to injuries to Kyle Wright and Charlie Morton, Atlanta ran out Max Fried for only his second start in a month (due to an absence for a blister) for game two and then a struggling Bryce Elder for game three.
And with the news that Wright’s also going to miss all of 2024 after shoulder surgery, it’s believed that Atlanta’s going to go out and prioritize adding a frontline starter…even IF Charlie Morton returns on a $20M club option for his age 40 season.
And one of the names most commonly floated around by fans has been Trevor Bauer.
The 2020 National League Cy Young winner with the Cincinnati Reds, he was 17 starts into a three-year, $102M pact with Los Angeles Dodgers in 2021 before a sexual assault allegation and a MLB suspension unceremoniously ended his season and, ultimately, his Dodgers tenure. He pitched in Japan last season after no MLB team offered him a contract for 2023.
Let’s talk about the pros and cons of signing Trevor Bauer if you’re the Atlanta Braves.
Why would you want to sign Trevor Bauer?
From a baseball perspective, this is easy, right? He’s got a 83-69 career record with a 3.79 ERA, which is solidly a floor of a #3 pitcher in MLB. And he’s recently removed from winning the Cy Young after a dominant, albeit short, 2020 season: 5-4, 1.73 ERA and 0.795 WHIP.
While he didn’t show the ceiling to live up to his top prospect status over the first few years of his career, his 2021 campaign was more in line with the Cy Young season, with a 2.59 ERA and 8-5 record over his first 17 Dodgers starts prior to be placed on the restricted list and ultimately released.
e’s not an easy answer on this one, because there’s both competitive concerns and off-the-field questions
So based on his previous performance, he’d be somewhere between a #3 and #2 pitcher for Atlanta, but (theoretically) at a much lower contract amount than equivalent options on the free market.
A previous proponent of one year deals and “betting on himself”, Bauer signed for three years and $102M with the Dodgers, giving himself player option for the 2022 and 2023 seasons for maximum leverage.
Theoretically, the contract situation for Bauer now would be significantly different.
He’s not leveraging a Cy Young victory to get the highest possible salary, he’s attempting to get back into MLB. A shorter term deal with a modest AAV seems most likely in this scenario. I could see a team offering $15M on a one-year deal, or perhaps $20M on a two-year deal, and he may attempt to negotiate either a player option or, more likely, an opt-out in case he does return to frontline starter form.
(And financially, he’s doing fine. He spent the entire 2023 season pitching in Japan for a maximum of $4M while also receiving his full Dodgers salary for 2023. He’s estimated to have earned $104M over his 13 seasons in professional baseball.)
The delta – the space between his level of pay and his on-field performance – has the possibility of being quite significant in this case.
Why would you NOT want to sign Trevor Bauer?
It’s a distraction, and potentially a big one.
We’re deliberately not going to go into full details of the accusations against Bauer, but there were multiple accusations, related to sexual matters and violence, from multiple women levied against him that prompted the record-length 324 day MLB suspension under its domestic violence policy (lowered to 194 on appeal).
So, should Atlanta do it?
I don’t know. It’s not an easy decision, or one that’s strictly just a baseball decision. Any MLB organization considering signing Trevor Bauer needs to have not just a baseball conversation, but include in folks from communications, ownership, and yes, the current players.
(To his credit, Jake suggests discussing the potential with some of the current roster, singling out Travis D’Arnaud as a clubhouse leader that should be able to weigh in on the rosters’ overall sentiment towards a potential signing.)
My gut says that Atlanta won’t do it – the lack of an individual owner to step up and take…well, ownership of the situation, as well as the franchise’s relatively low past history of “loud” and “distracting” players compared to other organizations, makes me doubt the Braves will pull the trigger.
But you never know – Alex Anthopoulos has stated that they are looking into every conceivable roster upgrade to ensure a repeat trip to the postseason and (ideally) a far deeper playoff run than they have seen in recent years. At this moment, almost anything is possible.
(Except maybe Atlanta blowing out the bank to contract anyone for more over $22M/year. That appears to be the one bridge they’ve come close to crossing – Freddie’s stated final bid would have been just over $23M – but have yet to cross.)
